SIVR vs SLV: What's the Difference?
Aberdeen Standard Physical Silver Shares ETF (SIVR) and iShares Silver Trust (SLV) follow the LBMA Silver Price, so a buyer gets the same underlying portfolio from either one. What separates SIVR from SLV is cost, trading and fund details, not holdings.
Put simply, SIVR has the lower expense ratio (0.30% vs 0.50%); SLV trades about 9x the dollar volume; SLV has a track record that goes back to 2006. Below we compare SIVR vs SLV on cost, performance, total return, liquidity and risk, so you can see which features matter for your own strategy.
What is SIVR?
Aberdeen Standard Physical Silver Shares ETF has been trading since July 2009, run by Aberdeen, with $3.5B in assets.
- Expense ratio: 0.30% a year.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $102M.
- Share price: $46.40.
What is SLV?
iShares Silver Trust launched in April 2006, run by BlackRock, with $25.7B in assets.
- Expense ratio: 0.50% a year.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $927M.
- Share price: $44.13.
Expense Ratio and Cost of Ownership
Fees first. SIVR charges 0.30% and SLV 0.50% a year, which is $30 and $50 on a $10,000 position, a difference of about 20 basis points. The charge comes out of fund assets every day, so it never shows up on a statement, yet it works against your return the whole time you own the fund.
Try it with numbers: at an assumed 7% return before fees, 30 years of the lower fee are worth about $3,830 per $10,000 in favor of SIVR. The fee calculator above works for any amount and period.
Performance and Total Return
With one index behind both funds, SIVR and SLV deliver nearly the same results. Over five years the annualized total return was 13.72% for SIVR and 13.51% for SLV, or about +90.2% and +88.4% in cumulative terms. Over the past year SIVR returned -6.88% and SLV -6.94%.
Calendar-year returns tell the same story: in 2025 SIVR gained 145.34% and SLV gained 144.66%, and in 2022 SIVR gained 2.59% and SLV gained 2.37%. For the 10-year period the annualized return reads 10.58% (SIVR) against 10.36% (SLV). The small, steady gap in SIVR's favor is close to the difference in fees. Use the performance comparison chart to see growth of $10,000 and total return over 1 month to 5 years.
Why the returns are not exactly the same
Even on one index the results are never identical: fees, dividend timing, cash balances and trading costs all leave a small mark. For SIVR and SLV the net effect is a small gap each year. Volatility, drawdowns and beta are practically the same, so neither fund carries less market risk than the other.
Liquidity, Trading Volume and Options
On trading volume SLV is ahead, with roughly $927M changing hands daily (about 9x SIVR). SLV also has a larger options market in our data: 24 expiration dates against 10 and 49 strikes against 30 at the nearest expiration. That matters for active traders, large orders and option strategies such as covered calls or hedging.
SIVR trades about $102M a day. For a long-term investor buying shares a few times a year, both funds are liquid enough.
Structure, Taxes and the Wash Sale Rule
Taxes in a taxable account and a Roth IRA
SIVR and SLV are grantor trusts that hold the metal rather than stocks. Tax treatment of gains on such trusts can differ from regular stock ETFs, so check the rules for your account type and country with a tax adviser. In a Roth IRA or another tax-advantaged account, gains are not taxed along the way.
Are SIVR and SLV substantially identical?
Investors who sell one fund at a loss and buy the other often ask about the wash sale rule. The IRS has not published a clear definition of "substantially identical" for ETFs. SIVR and SLV track the LBMA Silver Price and are run by different issuers, and tax professionals differ on whether a switch between them is safe for tax-loss harvesting. Check with a tax adviser before relying on it.
SIVR or SLV: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
There is no single answer to "which is better, SIVR or SLV". The funds give the same market exposure, so the choice depends on how you invest. These are the factors investors usually weigh:
Long-term buy and hold, IRA and Roth IRA
For investors who plan to hold for many years, the expense ratio is the main cost, and SIVR's is lower. Liquidity matters less when you trade rarely.
Active trading, large orders and options
For frequent trading, very large orders or option strategies, SLV's higher trading volume can outweigh the 0.2 percentage point fee difference.
Track SIVR or SLV in your portfolio
Holding SIVR, SLV or both? Snowball Analytics shows what they have earned you, what they cost.
For information only. The comparison of SIVR and SLV above does not tell you what to buy, sell or hold and is not tax advice.
