VTI vs SPY: What's the Difference?
The index behind VTI is not the one behind SPY, yet their returns move almost in step (correlation 1.00). Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund ETF Shares (VTI) tracks the Morningstar US Total Market TR USD and holds 3,527 positions; SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) tracks the S&P 500 and holds 505 positions.
In short, SPY returned more over the past 10 years (15.10% vs 14.60% a year); VTI charges less (0.03% vs 0.0945%). Next: cost, performance, total return, dividends, liquidity and risk, one block at a time.
What is VTI?
Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund ETF Shares has been trading since May 2001, run by Vanguard, with $694.4B in assets. It follows the Morningstar US Total Market TR USD.
- Expense ratio: 0.03% a year.
- Holdings: 3,527 positions, 34.60% in information technology.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $1.2B.
- Share price: $371.11.
What is SPY?
SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust has been trading since January 1993, run by State Street, and has $801.0B in assets. It follows the S&P 500.
- Expense ratio: 0.0945% a year.
- Holdings: 505 positions, 39.80% in information technology.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $32.9B.
- Share price: $754.37.
Expense Ratio and Cost of Ownership
SPY costs 0.0945% a year to own and VTI 0.03%: about 6.5 basis points apart, or $9.45 against $3 per $10,000. Among the differences between VTI and SPY this is one you can measure exactly. The fee is taken from the fund's assets every day, so you never see it as a separate charge, but it lowers your return for as long as you hold the fund.
Small annual gaps add up. Assume both funds earn 7% before fees: after 30 years VTI leaves a $10,000 investment about $1,354 larger than SPY does. Use the fee calculator to try your own amount and horizon.
Tracking difference
Management fees are not the only cost. Tracking difference shows how far a fund's return fell behind the S&P 500 total return over the last 12 months: -0.09% for SPY. It includes the expense ratio and other costs. Our data has no comparable value for VTI.
Performance and Total Return
VTI and SPY track different indexes, but their portfolios are close, so performance is similar. Over five years the annualized total return was 10.47% for VTI and 11.54% for SPY, or about +64.5% and +72.6% in cumulative terms with dividends reinvested. Over the past year VTI returned 13.77% and SPY 13.46%.
Calendar-year returns show how far apart the two can be: in 2021 VTI gained 25.68% and SPY gained 28.73%, and in 2022 VTI lost 19.52% and SPY lost 18.18%. Stretch the window to 10 years and the annualized figures are 14.60% and 15.10%. For other windows, open the performance comparison chart (1 month to 5 years).
Risk: volatility, drawdowns and beta
Over the past year VTI's volatility was 13.81% and SPY's 13.66%, and the largest fall from a peak was 8.92% for VTI against 8.88% for SPY. The published 3-year beta is 1.00 for VTI and 0.97 for SPY. Bigger numbers here describe a fund that moves further in either direction.
Dividends: Yield, Payout and Frequency
Dividends from VTI and SPY arrive quarterly, in March, June, September and December. Yield over the last 12 months: 1.06% (VTI) and 1.01% (SPY).
In dollar terms, $10,000 would have produced roughly $106 from VTI and $101 from SPY over the year.
Looking at yield by calendar year, the high point was 2022 (1.67% for VTI, 1.65% for SPY). Because yield is the payout divided by the price, it can fall when the price rises even if the dividend does not shrink.
Liquidity, Trading Volume and Options
Liquidity is where SPY leads. It trades about $32.9B a day, about 27x more than VTI. SPY also has a larger options market in our data: 32 expiration dates against 9 (including daily expirations) and 162 strikes against 25 at the nearest expiration. That matters for active traders, large orders and option strategies such as covered calls or hedging.
VTI sees about $1.2B a day, which is still plenty for investors who buy a few times a year.
Share price and fractional shares
One VTI share costs $371.11 and one SPY share $754.37. The share price does not make a fund cheaper or more expensive, since $1,000 buys the same slice of a fund's portfolio either way. It matters only if your broker does not offer fractional shares.
Holdings and Sector Allocation
NVIDIA Corporation, Apple Inc and Microsoft Corporation sit among the biggest positions of both funds. In our data 48 of the 50 largest holdings of each fund are the same, and the 10 largest positions make up 38.87% of SPY against 32.89% of VTI.
The sector mix shows the difference most clearly. Information Technology is the largest sector in both funds: 34.60% of VTI and 39.80% of SPY.
VTI or SPY: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
There is no single answer to "which is better, VTI or SPY". The portfolios are close, so the choice rests on cost, size and trading rather than on what you own. These are the factors investors usually weigh:
What the data shows for VTI
VTI follows the Morningstar US Total Market TR USD, charges 0.03% a year, holds 3,527 positions, has 34.60% in information technology and yielded 1.06% over the last 12 months. It returned 14.60% a year over the past 10 years, with 13.81% volatility over the past year.
What the data shows for SPY
SPY follows the S&P 500, holds 505 positions, charges 0.0945% a year, has 39.80% in information technology and yielded 1.01% over the last 12 months. It returned 15.10% a year over the past 10 years, with 13.66% volatility over the past year.
Track VTI or SPY in your portfolio
Holding VTI, SPY or both? Snowball Analytics shows what they have earned you, what they cost and when the next dividend arrives.
The text above describes the data and is not advice: it is no recommendation on VTI or SPY, and no investment or tax guidance.

