VTV vs VUG: What's the Difference?
These two funds are not substitutes. Vanguard Value Index Fund ETF Shares (VTV) tracks the Morningstar US Large Cap Value TR USD and holds 311 positions, and Vanguard Growth Index Fund ETF Shares (VUG) tracks the Morningstar US Large Cap Growth TR USD and holds 139 positions.
The main points: VUG returned more over the past 10 years (17.45% vs 12.72% a year); VTV had the lower volatility over the past year (10.80% vs 19.02%); both charge 0.03% a year; VTV has the higher dividend yield (1.81% vs 0.41%). Next: cost, performance, total return, dividends, liquidity and risk, one block at a time.
What is VTV?
Vanguard Value Index Fund ETF Shares has been trading since January 2004, run by Vanguard, with $196.9B in assets. It follows the Morningstar US Large Cap Value TR USD.
- Expense ratio: 0.03% a year.
- Holdings: 311 positions, 23.21% in financials.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $630M.
- Share price: $229.51.
What is VUG?
Vanguard Growth Index Fund ETF Shares launched in January 2004, run by Vanguard and manages $221.3B. It follows the Morningstar US Large Cap Growth TR USD.
- Expense ratio: 0.03% a year.
- Holdings: 139 positions, 61.42% in information technology.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $527M.
- Share price: $84.23.
Expense Ratio and Cost of Ownership
The expense ratio does not separate VTV from VUG: both funds charge 0.03% a year, or $3 on a $10,000 investment. The charge comes out of fund assets every day, so it never shows up on a statement, yet it works against your return the whole time you own the fund.
Performance and Total Return
VTV and VUG track different indexes, so their performance can differ a lot. Over five years the annualized total return was 12.19% for VTV and 10.18% for VUG, or about +77.7% and +62.4% in cumulative terms with dividends reinvested. Over the past year VTV returned 24.89% and VUG 5.10%.
Year by year the picture is far apart: in 2023 VTV gained 9.32% and VUG gained 46.83%, and in 2022 VTV lost 2.09% and VUG lost 33.16%. Stretch the window to 10 years and the annualized figures are 12.72% and 17.45%. For other windows, open the performance comparison chart (1 month to 5 years).
Risk: volatility, drawdowns and beta
Over the past year VTV's volatility was 10.80% and VUG's 19.02%, and the largest fall from a peak was 6.35% for VTV against 15.07% for VUG. The published 3-year beta is 0.65 for VTV and 1.24 for VUG. Bigger numbers here describe a fund that moves further in either direction.
Dividends: Yield, Payout and Frequency
VTV and VUG both pay dividends quarterly, in March, June, September and December. The trailing 12-month yield is 1.81% for VTV and 0.41% for VUG.
In dollar terms, $10,000 would have produced roughly $181 from VTV and $41 from VUG over the year. The companies in VTV pay out a larger share of their earnings (payout ratio 34.64% vs 11.46%). VTV's dividend grew faster over the last year, by 6.77% against 1.47%.
Liquidity, Trading Volume and Options
Trading volume is similar, about $630M a day for VTV and $527M for VUG. Both funds have listed options; neither has daily expirations. Liquidity will rarely decide between the two.
Share price and fractional shares
One VTV share costs $229.51 and one VUG share $84.23. The share price does not make a fund cheaper or more expensive, since $1,000 buys the same slice of a fund's portfolio either way. It matters only if your broker does not offer fractional shares.
Holdings and Sector Allocation
In our data none of the 50 largest holdings of each fund are the same, and the 10 largest positions make up 61.32% of VUG against 23.75% of VTV.
The largest sector is financials in VTV (23.21%) and information technology in VUG (61.42%). Sector weights are where the two portfolios part ways.
Taxes and accounts
Both funds are US ETFs taxed the same way. In a taxable account you pay tax on dividends each year, so VTV's higher yield means more taxable income. In a Roth IRA or another tax-advantaged account this difference does not apply. Tax rules depend on your country and situation.
VTV or VUG: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
There is no single answer to "which is better, VTV or VUG". They are different portfolios, so the choice depends on what exposure you want. These are the factors investors usually weigh:
What the data shows for VTV
VTV follows the Morningstar US Large Cap Value TR USD, yielded 1.81% over the last 12 months, charges 0.03% a year, holds 311 positions and has 23.21% in financials. It returned 12.72% a year over the past 10 years, with 10.80% volatility over the past year.
What the data shows for VUG
VUG follows the Morningstar US Large Cap Growth TR USD, holds 139 positions, yielded 0.41% over the last 12 months, has 61.42% in information technology and charges 0.03% a year. It returned 17.45% a year over the past 10 years, with 19.02% volatility over the past year.
Track VTV or VUG in your portfolio
Put VTV or VUG into Snowball Analytics and see what you really earn, what you pay in fees and which dividends are coming, alongside everything else you own.
Nothing here is a recommendation about VTV or VUG; it summarizes the data on this page and is not investment or tax advice.
