XLF vs VFH: What's the Difference?
On paper the indexes differ, in practice the funds are close (correlation 1.00). Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) tracks the S&P Financial Select Sector and holds 80 positions, while Vanguard Financials Index Fund ETF Shares (VFH) tracks the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Financials and holds 432 positions.
In short, XLF returned more over the past 10 years (12.52% vs 12.20% a year); the fees are similar (0.08% and 0.09% a year); VFH has the higher dividend yield (1.66% vs 1.41%). Below we compare XLF vs VFH on cost, performance, total return, dividends, liquidity and risk, so you can see which features matter for your own strategy.
What is XLF?
Financial Select Sector SPDR Fund started in December 1998, run by State Street, and has $54.1B in assets. It follows the S&P Financial Select Sector.
- Expense ratio: 0.08% a year.
- Holdings: 80 positions, 100.22% in financials.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $1.9B.
- Share price: $58.68.
What is VFH?
Vanguard Financials Index Fund ETF Shares launched in January 2004, run by Vanguard, and has $13.6B in assets. It follows the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Financials.
- Expense ratio: 0.09% a year.
- Holdings: 432 positions, 96.24% in financials.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $87M.
- Share price: $141.79.
Expense Ratio and Cost of Ownership
On fees the two are close: 0.08% a year for XLF and 0.09% for VFH, which is $8 and $9 per $10,000 invested. Nobody sends a bill for it: the fee is deducted from the fund's assets daily, and it quietly reduces your return for every year you hold.
Performance and Total Return
The indexes differ, yet XLF and VFH have moved together closely. Over five years the annualized total return was 9.75% for XLF and 9.39% for VFH, or about +59.2% and +56.6% in cumulative terms with dividends reinvested. Over the past year XLF returned 12.51% and VFH 12.05%.
The calendar years show how far apart the two can be. Take 2023: XLF gained 12.03% and VFH gained 14.17%, and in 2022 XLF lost 10.59% and VFH lost 12.31%. For the 10-year period the annualized return reads 12.52% (XLF) against 12.20% (VFH). For other windows, open the performance comparison chart (1 month to 5 years).
Risk: volatility, drawdowns and beta
Over the past year XLF's volatility was 15.31% and VFH's 15.39%, and the largest fall from a peak was 14.79% for XLF against 14.75% for VFH. The published 3-year beta is 0.68 for XLF and 0.76 for VFH. Bigger numbers here describe a fund that moves further in either direction.
Dividends: Yield, Payout and Frequency
Both funds distribute quarterly, in March, June, September and December. The trailing 12-month yield is 1.41% for XLF and 1.66% for VFH.
In dollar terms, $10,000 would have produced roughly $141 from XLF and $166 from VFH over the year. The companies in VFH pay out a larger share of their earnings (payout ratio 26.16% vs 23.39%). VFH's dividend grew faster over the last year, by 14.23% against 12.38%.
Looking at yield by calendar year, the high point was 2022 (2.04% for XLF, 2.31% for VFH). Because yield is the payout divided by the price, it can fall when the price rises even if the dividend does not shrink.
Liquidity, Trading Volume and Options
XLF is the more heavily traded fund: about $1.9B a day, about 22x the volume of VFH. XLF also has a larger options market in our data: 22 expiration dates against 4 and 37 strikes against 21 at the nearest expiration. That matters for active traders, large orders and option strategies such as covered calls or hedging.
That leaves VFH at about $87M daily; investors who buy only occasionally will hardly notice the difference.
Share price and fractional shares
Price per share: XLF $58.68, VFH $141.79. Spending $1,000 buys the same share of either portfolio, so the price matters only without fractional shares.
Holdings and Sector Allocation
The two funds have some large names in common: JPMorgan Chase & Co, Berkshire Hathaway Inc and Visa Inc are among the largest holdings of both. In our data 49 of the 50 largest holdings of each fund are the same, and the 10 largest positions make up 56.61% of XLF against 47.81% of VFH.
The sector mix shows the difference most clearly. Financials is the largest sector in both funds: 100.22% of XLF and 96.24% of VFH.
Taxes and accounts
Both funds are taxed as US ETFs. Because VFH yields more, it generates more taxable dividends in a regular brokerage account; retirement accounts such as a Roth IRA remove that difference. Individual circumstances and local law apply.
XLF or VFH: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
Nothing in the data crowns one of XLF and VFH. Because the portfolios are so alike, practical points decide: fees, fund size and liquidity. Investors usually weigh these factors:
What the data shows for XLF
XLF follows the S&P Financial Select Sector, has 100.22% in financials, charges 0.08% a year, holds 80 positions and yielded 1.41% over the last 12 months. It returned 12.52% a year over the past 10 years, with 15.31% volatility over the past year.
What the data shows for VFH
VFH follows the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Financials, charges 0.09% a year, yielded 1.66% over the last 12 months, holds 432 positions and has 96.24% in financials. It returned 12.20% a year over the past 10 years, with 15.39% volatility over the past year.
Track XLF or VFH in your portfolio
See XLF and VFH the way you actually hold them: connect your accounts to Snowball Analytics and get returns, costs and payout dates calculated for you.
General information drawn from the data above; not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold XLF or VFH, and not investment or tax advice.
