XLP vs VDC: What's the Difference?
On paper the indexes differ, in practice the funds are close (correlation 0.99). Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLP) tracks the S&P Consumer Staples Select Sector and holds 37 positions, while Vanguard Consumer Staples Index Fund ETF Shares (VDC) tracks the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Consumer Staples and holds 110 positions.
Put simply, the fees are similar (0.08% and 0.09% a year); XLP has the higher dividend yield (2.38% vs 1.94%); VDC returned more over the past 10 years (9.49% vs 9.11% a year). The sections below go through cost, performance, total return, dividends, liquidity and risk for XLP and VDC.
What is XLP?
Consumer Staples Select Sector SPDR Fund started in December 1998, run by State Street, with $14.9B in assets. It follows the S&P Consumer Staples Select Sector.
- Expense ratio: 0.08% a year.
- Holdings: 37 positions, 98.49% in consumer staples.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $1.2B.
- Share price: $92.35.
What is VDC?
Vanguard Consumer Staples Index Fund ETF Shares has been trading since January 2004, run by Vanguard, and has $8.4B in assets. It follows the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Consumer Staples.
- Expense ratio: 0.09% a year.
- Holdings: 110 positions, 98.21% in consumer staples.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $41M.
- Share price: $251.77.
Expense Ratio and Cost of Ownership
The expense ratio hardly separates XLP from VDC: XLP charges 0.08% a year and VDC 0.09%, or $8 against $9 on a $10,000 investment. The fee is taken from the fund's assets every day, so you never see it as a separate charge, but it lowers your return for as long as you hold the fund.
Performance and Total Return
The indexes differ, yet XLP and VDC have moved together closely. Over the past year XLP returned 22.72% and VDC 22.15%. Over five years the annualized total return was 7.67% for XLP and 8.36% for VDC, or about +44.7% and +49.4% in cumulative terms with dividends reinvested.
Calendar-year returns show how far apart the two can be: in 2023 XLP lost 0.82% and VDC gained 2.39%, and in 2022 XLP lost 0.81% and VDC lost 1.79%. Stretch the window to 10 years and the annualized figures are 9.11% and 9.49%. Use the performance comparison chart to see growth of $10,000 and total return over 1 month to 5 years.
Risk: volatility, drawdowns and beta
Over the past year XLP's volatility was 15.71% and VDC's 15.32%, and the largest fall from a peak was 9.69% for XLP against 9.38% for VDC. The published 3-year beta is 0.39 for XLP and 0.40 for VDC. The higher the figure, the more the fund moves around.
Dividends: Yield, Payout and Frequency
XLP and VDC both pay dividends quarterly, in March, June, September and December. The trailing 12-month yield is 2.38% for XLP and 1.94% for VDC.
In dollar terms, $10,000 would have produced roughly $238 from XLP and $194 from VDC over the year. The companies in XLP pay out a larger share of their earnings (payout ratio 60.96% vs 51.26%). XLP's dividend grew faster over the last year, by 3.98% against 2.82%.
The yield by year in our data peaked in 2024: 2.77% for XLP and 2.33% for VDC. Yields move with the share price as well as with the payout, so a falling yield does not always mean a smaller dividend.
Liquidity, Trading Volume and Options
Liquidity is where XLP leads. It trades about $1.2B a day, about 29x more than VDC. XLP also has a larger options market in our data: 12 expiration dates against 4 and 48 strikes against 9 at the nearest expiration. That matters for active traders, large orders and option strategies such as covered calls or hedging.
VDC still trades roughly $41M a day, enough for most people who add to a position now and then.
Share price and fractional shares
A XLP share is $92.35 and a VDC share $251.77. That gap changes nothing about cost or return; it only matters when fractional shares are not available at your broker.
Holdings and Sector Allocation
Walmart Inc, Costco Wholesale Corporation and The Procter & Gamble Company sit among the biggest positions of both funds. In our data 33 of the 50 largest holdings of each fund are the same, and the 10 largest positions make up 65.06% of VDC against 63.72% of XLP.
The sector mix shows the difference most clearly. Consumer Staples is the largest sector in both funds: 98.49% of XLP and 98.21% of VDC. The biggest sector gap is in materials: 0.00% of XLP against 0.33% of VDC.
Taxes and accounts
The tax rules are the same for XLP and VDC. What differs is income: XLP pays out more each year, and in a taxable account that income is taxed. In tax-advantaged accounts such as a Roth IRA the gap does not matter. Check your own country and situation.
XLP or VDC: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
Nothing in the data crowns one of XLP and VDC. Because the portfolios are so alike, practical points decide: fees, fund size and liquidity. Investors usually weigh these factors:
What the data shows for XLP
XLP follows the S&P Consumer Staples Select Sector, has 98.49% in consumer staples, charges 0.08% a year, holds 37 positions and yielded 2.38% over the last 12 months. It returned 9.11% a year over the past 10 years, with 15.71% volatility over the past year.
What the data shows for VDC
VDC follows the MSCI US IMI 25/50 Consumer Staples, has 98.21% in consumer staples, holds 110 positions, yielded 1.94% over the last 12 months and charges 0.09% a year. It returned 9.49% a year over the past 10 years, with 15.32% volatility over the past year.
Track XLP or VDC in your portfolio
Holding XLP, VDC or both? Snowball Analytics shows what they have earned you, what they cost and when the next dividend arrives.
Nothing here is a recommendation about XLP or VDC; it summarizes the data on this page and is not investment or tax advice.
