Stock Comparison: AU vs AG (2026)

AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AU) and First Majestic Silver Corp (AG) both operate in metals & mining. Compare valuation, profitability, dividends and their safety, returns and risk, side by side. AU and AG are ADRs: shares of a foreign company traded in the US.

Page updated November 2026

Start tracking portfolio

Connect your brokerage and see your actual returns, dividends and fees for AU, AG and every other holding — automatically.
In short
  • Same industry. Both are in metals & mining; AU has a market cap of $43.7B and AG $6.7B.
  • AU returned more: 25.08% vs 5.62% a year over 10 years with 59.76% vs 73.83% volatility.
  • Valuation. AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6.
Stocks compared on this page
AngloGold Ashanti logo
AUAngloGold Ashanti Limited
vs
First Majestic Silver logo
AGFirst Majestic Silver Corp

AU vs AG: Performance Charts

AU and AG are two companies in the same industry, and the lines below show how their shares behaved. Growth is the total return, with dividends reinvested where the company pays them.

AU vs AG: Performance Comparison

Hypothetical growth of a $10,000 investment. Values include reinvested dividends.

AU$8,586-14.14%
AG$5,702-42.98%
May 13, 2026 to Nov 13, 2026Difference $2,884

Total Return (%)

Cumulative price change plus reinvested dividends from the start of the period.

AU-14.14%
AG-42.98%
May 13, 2026 to Nov 13, 2026Difference 28.84 pp
Data as of November 2026. Charts show past total returns, compiled by the Snowball Analytics team from third-party market data. Figures may be delayed or contain errors. Past performance does not predict future results. This comparison is general information, not investment advice. See the full disclaimer.

AU vs AG: The Short Answer

$10,000 invested in AU in November 2021 would be worth $47,425 today, against $10,029 in AG; over the past year AG was the more volatile (73.83% vs 59.76%). This is a result of the past, with total return including dividends, and not a forecast.

Month by month, AU beat AG in 30 of the last 48 months and AG beat AU in 18; the typical gap in a month was 9.6 percentage points.

When the two stocks moved apart

The months with the biggest gap in total return.

MonthAUAGGap
November 2022+40.46%+10.28%30.18 pp
June 2025+4.02%+34.04%30.02 pp
March 2023+46.51%+18.30%28.22 pp
January 2025+30.89%+3.82%27.07 pp

Worst drop from a peak

Over the whole period of the charts, on total return.

AU: -51.75% from March 2022 to the low in September 2022, back at the old high in April 2023.

AG: -70.28% from April 2022 to the low in February 2024, back at the old high in October 2025.

When AG moves 1% in a day, AU has moved by about 0.53% on average over the whole period and by 0.63% over the last 12 months. The correlation of daily returns is 0.66 over the whole period and 0.78 over the last 12 months.

AU vs AG: Key Differences

Market cap
$43.7Bvs$6.7B
AU is about 6x larger
Forward P/E
9.6vs14.8
Price over expected earnings
Revenue growth, last year
70.78%vs124.47%
Last fiscal year vs the one before
10-year return, a year
25.08%vs5.62%
Gap of 19.46 pp, total return

What is different, in short

AU and AG are in the same industry, so the differences are in scale, valuation, profitability and risk.

  • Scale. Revenue over the last 12 months was $12.0B for AU and $1.8B for AG; market cap $43.7B vs $6.7B.
  • Valuation. AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6; P/S is similar: 3.6 for AU and 3.8 for AG.
  • Profitability. AU has the higher operating margin: 50.39% vs 46.43%.
  • Growth. AU has the higher 3-year revenue growth: 30.02% vs 26.37% a year.
  • Dividends. AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%.
  • Risk. AG is more volatile (73.83% vs 59.76%) over the past year.

Factors investors usually weigh

Which factor matters more depends on how you invest. This is general information, not a recommendation.

IncomeHigher yield: AU

5.24% vs 0.29% over the last 12 months.

ValuationLower forward P/E: AU

9.6 vs 14.8; a lower multiple is not the same as a cheaper business.

GrowthFaster revenue growth: AG

124.47% vs 70.78% in the last fiscal year.

Smaller swingsLower volatility: AU

59.76% vs 73.83% over the past year.

AU vs AG: Head-To-Head Stock Comparison

Share price
$86.29 -1.50%
$13.65 -2.43%
Sector
Materials
Materials
Industry
Metals & Mining
Metals & Mining
Market cap
$43.7B Larger
$6.7B
Avg. daily $ volume
$260M Higher
$177M
P/E ratio
11.22
17.28
Forward P/E
9.55
14.76
P/S ratio
3.63
3.85
Dividend yield (TTM)
5.24% Higher
0.29%
Payout frequency
Quarterly
Quarterly
Payout ratio (earnings)
58.78%
5.80%
Years of dividend growth in a row
3
2
Beta (5Y, vs S&P 500)
0.75
2.19
Revenue (TTM)
$12.0B Higher
$1.8B
Net margin
32.63%
22.58%
First trading date
August 1998
November 2006
Exchange
NYSE
NYSE
ADR
Yes
Yes

"Larger" and "Higher" only mark the bigger number, not a better choice. Prices are closing prices as of November 2026 and may be delayed. Blank values are not available or not reliable.

Valuation: AU vs AG

On the multiples our data has, AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6; P/S is similar: 3.6 for AU and 3.8 for AG. A higher multiple means investors pay more per dollar of earnings or sales; it says nothing by itself about which stock is the better choice.

MultipleAUAG
P/E (TTM)11.2217.28
Forward P/E9.5514.76
PEG0.78—
P/S (TTM)3.633.85
P/B4.652.21
EV/EBITDA6.06.1

Multiples are as published by our data provider as of November 2026. P/E is price over trailing 12-month earnings, forward P/E uses expected earnings, PEG relates P/E to expected earnings growth, P/S is price over sales, P/B price over book value, EV/EBITDA enterprise value over earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization. Values that are negative or out of any sensible range are not shown.

Financials and Profitability: AU vs AG

AU has the higher operating margin: 50.39% vs 46.43%; AG has the higher last-year revenue growth: 124.47% vs 70.78%.

MetricAUAG
Revenue (TTM)$12.0B$1.8B
Revenue growth, last fiscal year70.78%124.47%
Revenue growth, 3-year CAGR30.02%26.37%
Gross margin54.84%63.48%
Operating margin50.39%46.43%
Net margin32.63%22.58%
Return on equity44.33%14.41%
Return on assets24.39%10.96%
Free cash flow (TTM)$3.6B$771M

Reported in USD; the last fiscal year ended December 2025 for AU and December 2025 for AG. Revenue and free cash flow are for the last 12 months, growth rates compare fiscal years.

Dividends: AU vs AG

Over the last 12 months AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%.

Dividend yield (TTM)
5.24%vs0.29%
Trailing 12 months
Annual payout per share
$4.52vs$0.04
Trailing 12 months
Last dividend
$0.72vs$0.01
Both paid in August 2026
Frequency
Quarterly
Mar, May, Aug, Nov

Dividend yield by year

Dividends paid in the year divided by the share price at the end of the year

AUAG
Track the next AU and AG payouts in your own portfolio and see your future dividend income.Open Dividend Tracker

Dividend Safety: AU vs AG

AU has the higher payout ratio of earnings: 58.78% vs 5.80%; streak of dividend increases is similar: 3 years for AU and 2 years for AG. A lower payout ratio leaves more room to keep paying, but a ratio alone does not guarantee a dividend.

MetricAUAG
Payout ratio, earnings (TTM)58.78%5.80%
Payout ratio, free cash flow (last FY)56.10%3.17%
Years of dividend growth in a row32
Years of dividend payments in a row32

Payout ratios show what share of earnings or free cash flow goes to dividends; values above 120% of free cash flow are not shown because the periods do not match. Years in a row follow Snowball Analytics data. Dividend growth rates are shown only where two independent calculations agree within 3 percentage points.

Performance: AU vs AG

Over the past 10 years AU returned 25.08% a year and AG 5.62%.

Calendar-year returns

Total return by year, 2026 is year to date

AUAG

Returns by period

Total return with dividends reinvested. Periods over 1 year are annualized (CAGR).

Stock1M6MYTD1Y3Y*5Y*10Y*Since launch*
AU-5.85%-14.14%+4.79%+11.89%+83.10%+36.81%+25.08%+7.14%
AG-16.41%-42.98%-17.91%+11.92%+44.51%-0.01%+5.62%+6.56%
Difference, pp+10.56+28.84+22.70-0.03+38.59+36.82+19.46-

* Annualized. "Since launch" starts at the first trading date in our price history, which differs between the two stocks. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Risk: AU vs AG

AG has been the riskier stock. Over the past year its volatility was 73.83% against 59.76% for AU and its largest fall was 57.28% against 39.91%. The correlation of 0.79 over the past year means the two stocks move together only partly.

MetricAUAGDifference
Volatility (1Y)59.76%73.83%14.07 pp
Max drawdown (1Y)-39.91%-57.28%17.37 pp
Current drawdown from peak-30.32%-57.28%26.96 pp
Sharpe ratio (1Y)0.140.110.03
Beta (5Y, vs S&P 500)0.752.191.44
Correlation between the stocks (1Y)0.79-

Volatility, drawdowns, Sharpe ratio and correlation are calculated on the same period for both stocks (the last 12 months). Beta is the 5-year monthly beta against the S&P 500 published by our data provider. Max drawdown is the largest fall from a peak to a low.

Company Profile: AU vs AG

AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AU)

  • Sector: Materials.
  • Industry: Metals & Mining (Gold).
  • Employees: 38,000.
  • ADR: AU is an American depositary receipt of a foreign company, not a share of a US company.

AngloGold Ashanti plc operates as a gold mining company in Africa, Australia, and the Americas. It explores for gold, as well as by-products, including silver and sulphuric acid. The company's flagship property includes 100% owned the Geita mine located in the Lake Victoria goldfields of the Geita region in northwestern Tanzania. AngloGold Ashanti plc was incorporated in 1944 and is headquartered in Greenwood Village, Colorado.

First Majestic Silver Corp (AG)

  • Sector: Materials.
  • Industry: Metals & Mining (Silver).
  • Country: Canada.
  • ADR: AG is an American depositary receipt of a foreign company, not a share of a US company.

First Majestic Silver Corp. engages in the acquisition, exploration, development, and production of mineral properties in North America. The company explores for silver and gold deposits. Its projects include the San Dimas silver/gold mine covering an area of approximately 71,867 hectares located in Durango State, Mexico; the Santa Elena silver/gold mine that covers an area of approximately 102,244 hectares located in Sonora State, Mexico; the Los Gatos Silver Mine covering an area of approximately 103,000 hectares located in Chihuahua, Mexico; and the La Encantada silver mine that covers an area of approximately 4,076 hectares located in Coahuila State, Mexico. The company was formerly known as First Majestic Resource Corp. and changed its name to First Majestic Silver Corp. in November 2006. First Majestic Silver Corp. was incorporated in 1979 and is headquartered in Vancouver, Canada.

Business descriptions are quoted from our data provider (Yahoo Finance) without changes.

Already hold AU, AG or both? See what they really earn and pay you

Connect your brokerage account to automatically track returns, fees and dividends across your whole portfolio, or use Portfolio Lab to backtest AU or AG in your own allocation with real historical data.

Start tracking for free Model in Portfolio Lab See live demo

Investing in AU or AG from Outside the US

AU and AG are US-listed stocks. For investors in other countries, taxes and local rules can matter as much as the choice between the two.

Tax withheld on dividends

Dividends from US stocks paid to non-US investors are usually taxed at 30% at source, or 15% in many countries with a US tax treaty after you file form W-8BEN with your broker. AU and AG are ADRs: the company is based outside the US, and the tax on its dividends can depend on that country as well as on US rules. Check this with your broker.

Access from the EU and UK

Brokers in the EU and UK offer US stocks in different ways. Availability and costs depend on your broker and country.

Tax treatment and access depend on your country of residence and your broker. This is general information, not tax or investment advice; check the rules with your broker or a tax adviser.

AU vs AG: What's the Difference?

AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AU) and First Majestic Silver Corp (AG) both belong to metals & mining, with market caps of $43.7B and $6.7B. This page sets them side by side on valuation, profitability, dividends, returns and risk.

In short, over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year; AG was more volatile over the past year (73.83% vs 59.76%); AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%. Below we compare AU vs AG on valuation, profitability, dividends and dividend safety, returns and risk.

What is AU?

AngloGold Ashanti Limited is listed on NYSE and its share price history in our data starts in August 1998.

  • Market cap: $43.7B.
  • Revenue (last 12 months): $12.0B.
  • Share price: $86.29.
  • Average daily dollar volume: about $260M.
  • ADR: yes, a foreign company traded in the US.

What is AG?

First Majestic Silver Corp is listed on NYSE and its share price history in our data starts in November 2006.

  • Market cap: $6.7B.
  • Revenue (last 12 months): $1.8B.
  • Share price: $13.65.
  • Average daily dollar volume: about $177M.
  • ADR: yes, a foreign company traded in the US.

Valuation: What You Pay for Each Dollar

On the multiples in our data, AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6; AG has the higher trailing P/E: 17.3 vs 11.2; price-to-sales ratio is similar: 3.6 for AU and 3.8 for AG; EV/EBITDA is similar: 6.0 for AU and 6.1 for AG. A higher multiple means investors currently pay more for each dollar of earnings or sales; it does not tell you whether the stock is expensive or cheap for what it delivers.

Profitability and Growth

AG has the higher gross margin: 63.48% vs 54.84%; AU has the higher operating margin: 50.39% vs 46.43%; AG has the higher revenue growth in the last fiscal year: 124.47% vs 70.78%; AU has the higher three-year revenue growth: 30.02% vs 26.37%.

Free cash flow over the last 12 months was $3.6B for AU and $771M for AG.

Dividends: Yield, Payout and Safety

Over the last 12 months AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%. AU has the higher payout ratio of earnings: 58.78% vs 5.80%. Streak of dividend increases is similar: 3 years for AU and 2 years for AG (Snowball Analytics data). A dividend is paid at the company's discretion, and a low payout ratio does not guarantee it.

Returns and Risk

Over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year; AG was more volatile over the past year (73.83% vs 59.76%).

Month by month, AU was ahead in 30 of the last 48 months, with a typical monthly gap of 9.6 percentage points.

The worst fall from a peak over the period of the charts was -51.75% for AU (bottom in September 2022) and -70.28% for AG (bottom in February 2024).

The daily returns of the two stocks had a correlation of 0.66 over the whole period and 0.78 over the last 12 months, so how closely they move together has changed.

Liquidity and Options

AU trades about $260M a day, about 1.5x more than AG ($177M). Both are liquid enough for most individual orders.

ADRs

AU and AG are ADRs, which means the company is based outside the US and its shares trade in the US as depositary receipts. Currency, local taxes and the rules of the home country can matter in addition to the numbers on this page.

AU or AG: Which One Fits Your Strategy?

There is no single answer to "which is the better buy, AU or AG". The data shows differences, and which of them matters depends on your goals and horizon.

What the data shows for AU

AU has a market cap of $43.7B, a forward P/E of 9.6, an operating margin of 50.39% and yielded 5.24%.

What the data shows for AG

AG has a market cap of $6.7B, a forward P/E of 14.8, an operating margin of 46.43% and yielded 0.29%.

Track AU or AG in your portfolio

Add AU or AG to Snowball Analytics to see your real total return and your upcoming dividends next to the rest of your holdings.

This section is general information based on the data above. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold AU or AG, and not investment or tax advice.

Frequently Asked Questions: AU vs AG

What is the difference between AU and AG?
Both are in metals & mining. AU has a market cap of $43.7B and AG $6.7B. In our data, over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year.
Which is bigger, AU or AG?
AU. Its market cap is $43.7B against $6.7B for AG.
Which has performed better, AU or AG?
Over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
Which pays a higher dividend, AU or AG?
AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29% over the last 12 months.
Are the AU and AG dividends safe?
The data shows the payout ratio of earnings: 58.78% for AU and 5.80% for AG. A lower ratio leaves more room to keep paying, but no ratio guarantees a dividend. This is not investment advice.
Which is more volatile, AU or AG?
AG was more volatile over the past year (73.83% vs 59.76%).
Which has the higher P/E, AU or AG?
AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6. A higher multiple means investors pay more per dollar of expected earnings; it is not a verdict on the stock.
Is AU an ADR?
In our data AU and AG are foreign issuers, that is ADRs: the company is based outside the US and trades in the US as a depositary receipt.
Which is the better buy, AU or AG?
The data does not name a better buy. AU and AG differ in size, valuation, profitability and risk, and which of these matters depends on your goals and horizon. Compare the figures above; this is general information, not investment advice.

Data & Methodology

Data and update date

Market data as of November 2026. Prices, returns, company facts, valuation, financials and dividends come from our data providers. Comparisons, differences and all texts on this page are calculated by Snowball Analytics using the methods below.

Show full methodologyHide methodology

Returns

Total return with dividends reinvested. Periods longer than one year are annualized (CAGR). The charts use daily closing prices adjusted for dividends: each period starts on the first trading day on or after the start date, and both stocks always start on the same day.

Monthly comparison, drawdown and sensitivity

Monthly returns use the last trading day of each calendar month. The worst fall is the largest drop from a peak to a later low in the adjusted close over the whole period. Sensitivity is the slope of the daily returns of one stock on the daily returns of the other; correlation is calculated on the same daily returns.

Valuation and financials

Multiples and financial figures are as published by our data provider (Yahoo Finance). Trailing P/E, net margin and return on equity are left out when net income is driven by a one-off; ratios that are negative or out of range are not shown.

Dividends

Yield (TTM) = dividends paid over the last 12 months / current share price

Years of dividend growth follow Snowball Analytics data. Dividend growth rates are shown only where two independent calculations agree within 3 percentage points.

Risk

Volatility is the annualized standard deviation of daily returns. Max drawdown is the largest fall from a peak to a low within the period. Sharpe ratio is return above the 3-month Treasury bill rate divided by volatility. These metrics use the last 12 months for both stocks. Beta is the 5-year monthly beta against the S&P 500.

Disclaimer

Data as of November 2026. This page compares publicly available data on AU and AG. It was compiled by the Snowball Analytics team from third-party data providers and publicly available sources. The data may be incomplete, and figures may be delayed, out of date or contain errors; check them against the companies' own reports before making any decision.

Not investment advice. This is a side-by-side comparison of data, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, and not investment, tax or legal advice. Labels such as "Larger" or "Higher" only describe the numbers and do not say which stock is better for you. The information is general and not personalised to your circumstances.

No liability. The information is provided "as is", without warranties of any kind. Snowball Analytics is a portfolio tracking tool, not a broker-dealer or investment adviser, and is not liable for any loss or damage arising from the use of this page or reliance on its content.

Risk. Past performance does not predict future results. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal.