AU vs AG: What's the Difference?
AngloGold Ashanti Limited (AU) and First Majestic Silver Corp (AG) both belong to metals & mining, with market caps of $43.7B and $6.7B. This page sets them side by side on valuation, profitability, dividends, returns and risk.
In short, over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year; AG was more volatile over the past year (73.83% vs 59.76%); AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%. Below we compare AU vs AG on valuation, profitability, dividends and dividend safety, returns and risk.
What is AU?
AngloGold Ashanti Limited is listed on NYSE and its share price history in our data starts in August 1998.
- Market cap: $43.7B.
- Revenue (last 12 months): $12.0B.
- Share price: $86.29.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $260M.
- ADR: yes, a foreign company traded in the US.
What is AG?
First Majestic Silver Corp is listed on NYSE and its share price history in our data starts in November 2006.
- Market cap: $6.7B.
- Revenue (last 12 months): $1.8B.
- Share price: $13.65.
- Average daily dollar volume: about $177M.
- ADR: yes, a foreign company traded in the US.
Valuation: What You Pay for Each Dollar
On the multiples in our data, AG has the higher forward P/E: 14.8 vs 9.6; AG has the higher trailing P/E: 17.3 vs 11.2; price-to-sales ratio is similar: 3.6 for AU and 3.8 for AG; EV/EBITDA is similar: 6.0 for AU and 6.1 for AG. A higher multiple means investors currently pay more for each dollar of earnings or sales; it does not tell you whether the stock is expensive or cheap for what it delivers.
Profitability and Growth
AG has the higher gross margin: 63.48% vs 54.84%; AU has the higher operating margin: 50.39% vs 46.43%; AG has the higher revenue growth in the last fiscal year: 124.47% vs 70.78%; AU has the higher three-year revenue growth: 30.02% vs 26.37%.
Free cash flow over the last 12 months was $3.6B for AU and $771M for AG.
Dividends: Yield, Payout and Safety
Over the last 12 months AU has the higher dividend yield: 5.24% vs 0.29%. AU has the higher payout ratio of earnings: 58.78% vs 5.80%. Streak of dividend increases is similar: 3 years for AU and 2 years for AG (Snowball Analytics data). A dividend is paid at the company's discretion, and a low payout ratio does not guarantee it.
Returns and Risk
Over the past 10 years AU returned more, 25.08% vs 5.62% a year; AG was more volatile over the past year (73.83% vs 59.76%).
Month by month, AU was ahead in 30 of the last 48 months, with a typical monthly gap of 9.6 percentage points.
The worst fall from a peak over the period of the charts was -51.75% for AU (bottom in September 2022) and -70.28% for AG (bottom in February 2024).
The daily returns of the two stocks had a correlation of 0.66 over the whole period and 0.78 over the last 12 months, so how closely they move together has changed.
Liquidity and Options
AU trades about $260M a day, about 1.5x more than AG ($177M). Both are liquid enough for most individual orders.
ADRs
AU and AG are ADRs, which means the company is based outside the US and its shares trade in the US as depositary receipts. Currency, local taxes and the rules of the home country can matter in addition to the numbers on this page.
AU or AG: Which One Fits Your Strategy?
There is no single answer to "which is the better buy, AU or AG". The data shows differences, and which of them matters depends on your goals and horizon.
What the data shows for AU
AU has a market cap of $43.7B, a forward P/E of 9.6, an operating margin of 50.39% and yielded 5.24%.
What the data shows for AG
AG has a market cap of $6.7B, a forward P/E of 14.8, an operating margin of 46.43% and yielded 0.29%.
Track AU or AG in your portfolio
Add AU or AG to Snowball Analytics to see your real total return and your upcoming dividends next to the rest of your holdings.
This section is general information based on the data above. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold AU or AG, and not investment or tax advice.

